Topics
Latest
AI
Amazon
Image Credits:TechCrunch
Apps
Biotech & Health
Climate
Image Credits:TechCrunch
Cloud Computing
mercantilism
Crypto
Signal president Meredith Whittaker and Devin Coldewey at StrictlyVC LA.Image Credits:TechCrunch
endeavour
EVs
Fintech
fund-raise
Gadgets
Gaming
Government & Policy
Hardware
Layoffs
Media & Entertainment
Meta
Microsoft
Privacy
Robotics
Security
societal
Space
Startups
TikTok
Transportation
speculation
More from TechCrunch
Events
Startup Battlefield
StrictlyVC
Podcasts
television
Partner Content
TechCrunch Brand Studio
Crunchboard
Contact Us
‘We’re seeing surveillance wine in accountability bottles’
AI is “ not assailable in any sensation , ” the battle over encoding is far from won , and Signal ’s principled ( and uncompromising ) approach may complicate interoperability effort , warned the caller ’s chairman , Meredith Whittaker . But it ’s not all bad intelligence .
( Actually , it is all high-risk news , because Iwrote up the good news separately . )
Speaking onstage with me at StrictlyVC LA , Whittaker called out a resurgence of legislative attacks on encoding as “ magical intellection . ”
“ We ’re find a figure of , I would say , insular and very politically motivated pieces of legislation often indexed on the idea of protect kid . And these have been used to push for something that ’s actually a very previous wish of security system religious service , government activity autocrats , which is to consistently backdoor strong encryption , ” said Whittaker . “ Often , I think , pushed by well - mean people who just do n’t have the knowledge or education to understand the implications of what they ’re doing , that could , you live , essentially wipe out the power to communicate in private digitally . ”
Ironically , or perhaps cynically , one of the animating factors has been a decennium of call option for tech companies to take more obligation .
An encryption Book of Exodus bulk large over UK ’s Online Safety Bill
Join us at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
Exhibit at TechCrunch Sessions: AI
“ The overall theme I ’m seeing is a deep desire for answerableness in tech , which we saw sort of animise mid-2010s . That , then , has been weaponize , and I consider we ’re take in surveillance wine in accountability bottles , ” she enjoin .
“ ‘ Accountability ’ looks like more admonisher , more inadvertence , more back door , more elimination of property where masses can express or transmit freely , instead of actually assure on the line of work models that have created , you know , massive platforms whose surveillance advertising modalities can be easily weaponized for information ops , or doxing , or whatever it is , right ? There ’s an unwillingness to hit at the theme of the trouble . And or else , what we see is effectively proposal to draw out surveillance into government and NGO sectors in the name of accountability . ”
One such proposal come via the Investigatory Powers Act in the United Kingdom , under which the administration therethreatens to prevent any app updates — globally — that it take for a threat to its national security department .
“ [ The IPA ] is in effect claiming for the U.K. the ability to demand that any tech party , across all jurisdiction , fit in with the U.K. government before you ship a security department spot , because they may be overwork that piece somewhere for some business they require to keep doing . It ’s a form of , again , insular , witching thought here , ” said Whittaker .
“ It ’s very dangerous because we are being threaten to a return before the liberalization of encryption in 1999 , kind of an early ’ 90s paradigm where the government has a monopoly on encryption and the rightfulness to digital privacy . And where the ability to deploy encryption or seclusion update or anything that would secure and harden your serve becomes something you have to get license from the government to do . ”
“ And frankly , ” she bestow , “ I call up we call for the VC community , and the large tech companies more tortuous in naming what a scourge this is to the industriousness , and pushing back . ”
One bit of regulation that might seem to make mother wit is the messaging interoperability mandate being quest for in the EU via the Digital Markets Act . But this , too , has hide perils .
“ I retrieve the flavor urinate a tidy sum of sense . But of course Signal ca n’t interoperate with another messaging platform , without them raising their privacy bar significantly , ” even ones like WhatsApp that support death - to - remainder encryption and already partially apply the protocol . “ Because we do n’t just encrypt the content of messages using the Signal protocol . We encrypt metadata , we code your profile name , your profile photo , who ’s in your contact tilt , who you babble out to , when you talk to them . That would require to be the level of concealment and security agree across the gameboard with anyone we interoperated with before we could consent to interoperate . ”
There ’s a risk , she explain , that the opposite would hap , watering down security and privacy in the name of comfort station . “ It could actually deteriorate the standard of privateness , create kind of an interoperating monolith that further relegates those who are demand a touchstone of privacy with a lot of wholeness to a more marginal side . ” ( accidentally , she ridiculed the approximation ofApple get a passand forget any such authorities hopelessly fragmentize . )
In the private sphere , Whittaker was ready to call the ascendant Nvidia a monopolist .
“ It ’s the chip monopoly — and the CUDA monopoly , ” she said , referring to the proprietary computational architecture at the heart of much high - performance calculation today .
How much are Nvidia ’s rivals indue in startup ? We investigated
I asked if she thinks the party has become severe in its aggregation of power .
“ I mean , we have a lot of Spider - Men pointing at each other , right ? I ’m reckon Microsoft pointing fingerbreadth at Nvidia now , and saying , if you ’re distressed about monopoly , do not look to poor Microsoft , look to Nvidia , they ’re the unity , and you also look to Google . Google put out this variety of PR missive last week , kind of their AI entree principle , and they talked about Google being the only vertically integrated company from app store to fries . And that ’s true , correct ? But then Google published a couplet of days later , like Microsoft is actually the monopoly because it has the OpenAI and sort of the Azure monopoly , proper ?
“ So like , no one is innocent here . There ’s a lot of like , ‘ We ’re all trying to notice the hombre who did this … ’ ” ( i.e. , thefamous ‘ hot dog guy ’ memelifted from “ I Think You Should Leave with Tim Robinson ” ) .
“ I think we need to recognize that AI is subordinate on Big Tech . It requires Big Tech resources . It is not open in any sense , ” she said . “ We can be honest that , if you necessitate $ 100 million for a training rivulet , that is not an open resource , right ? If you need $ 100 million to deploy at weighing machine for a calendar month , that is not unresolved , proper ? So we need to be reliable about how we ’re using these footing . But I do n’t want the deviation toward Nvidia as the perpetrator of the hebdomad to detract from what we ’re dealing with this massively hard power . ”
you’re able to watch the full interview below .
