When you purchase through links on our site , we may bring in an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it works .
Middle children , rejoice : A unexampled field of study find that you ’re more conformable , honest and humble than your older and vernal siblings .
But do n’t triumph too clamorously at your vacation meal ( not that you would , being so low ) . The research contradicts late large study on birth order and personality and will likely necessitate more research to repeat the determination .
Are you the middle child? One new study suggests you may be the nicest of your siblings.
Stereotypes abound
There are plenteousness of pop music - psychological science stereotype about how one ’s birth order affects personality , from the overachieving first born to the peacekeeping in-between children to queer infant of the household . But most research has not supported these stereotypes . A 2015 commentary in the journalPNASnoted that studies over two decades found wildly contradictory resultant , with some showing very stiff correlations between personality traits and nascency order and others finding none at all . Many of these study were small , non - representative samples .
In 2015 , two studies with large samples were published . One looked at 20,000 people in the U.S. , U.K. and Germany and tried to find relationship between birth decree andpersonality traitsas measured by the Big Five – five stock psychological categories of personality that are well - supported by research . ( They are extraversion / introversion , agreeableness , nakedness to experience , neuroticism and painstakingness . ) The other study did something similar with a sampling of 272,000 U.S. adults who attended high school day in 1960 and are part of a long - consort study call up Project Talent .
Neither discipline made much of a case for birth ordering influencing personality . Thethree - country subject found no relationship , while theProject Talent studyfound a very small relationship between intelligence operation and being an senior sibling , perhaps indicate that old sibling benefit from teaching their younger sibling . Still , despite this statistically detectable divergence , a untested sib will still mark higher on an intelligence quotient examination than their older sib in four out of ten cases , the researchers wrote , mean the finding has determine exponent to predict intelligence in the real man .
Related : Are these 4 personality types for genuine ?
New dataset
Now , a Modern field reason that there are deviation – and that crucially , they look on kinsperson size . This study , published Monday ( Dec. 23 ) in the journalPNAS , used a different personality measure called HEXACO , which was develop by Michael Ashtona and Kibeom Lee , the two authors of the new study . HEXACO overlap with the Big Five personality dimensions , but with some differences . Its categories are honesty / humility , emotionality , extraversion , agreeableness , conscientiousness and nakedness to experience . amenity in HEXACO means a tendency toward tractability , thanksgiving , and pardon , whereas agreeableness in the Big Five is specify by warmth and cooperation .
The investigator used data from hexaco.org , where anyone can take a personality trial run to incur out where they go down on this weighing machine . For 710,797 individuals , they had information about parturition order . For another 74,920 individuals , they had information about both parentage order and number of siblings . ( These studies do not differentiate between step - sibling , half sib or other biological relationships , instead specify sibling as any other children in the household . )
In this dataset , the researchers find that middle minor had the highest score for honesty / humility and for agreeableness , followed by immature sib , then oldest , then only tike . They also find that the more sibling a person had , the high they scored in these same traits .
Because religious families tend to have more children , the researchers controlled for pietism and establish that religion explain about 25 % of these differences , but that still left birth fiat and family size creditworthy for the rest . The differences between sibling are small-scale , but the author job that they could be due to the forced cooperation that pass off in large families .
— What are ' attachment style , ' and is there science to back them up ?
— ' you could not put masses into arbitrary box ' : Psychologists critique the ' 5 love languages '
— Was Sigmund Freud the right way about anything ?
" A commonsense possibility is that when one has more sibling , one must more frequently collaborate rather than act on selfish taste , " Lee and Ashtona wrote . " This ongoing situation might then promote the development of accommodative tendencies by and large . "
These findings are not likely to be the last word in birth rescript research , however . In 2020 , for model , another study searching for difference between only children and shaver with siblings turned upno differences in narcissism . Anda 2019 studycomparing only tiddler and citizenry with siblings using HEXACO found only vanishingly small differences .
