When you purchase through liaison on our land site , we may earn an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it works .
" The Iceman " Wim Hofclaims a compounding of respire employment and cold vulnerability can bring people many benefits , including increased willpower ; fat going ; a " bastioned " immune response ; " balanced " hormones ; and reduce redness .
The panel is still out onwhether the Wim Hof Method ( WHM ) has any of these benefits , but are the teaching also serious ?
Wim Hof talks to one of his trainees in Poland in 2016.
expert secern Live Science that some of Hof ’s practices , as usher in some video online , lay a risk of drowning , as well as potentially dangerous heart - calendar method irregularities . However , a interpreter for the WHM said these TV are not brooding of the official method acting , but plainly examples of Hof doing " extreme exploit , " and that they supply safety videos and didactics on their website explain how to safely practice the WHM .
Whatever the prescribed direction on the WHM website states , some Wim Hof - branded social media videos give a very different , and serious , notion of how to rehearse the method acting , experts say . What ’s more , there is grounds that hoi polloi have break doing WHM external respiration exercises while in pee .
Related : How to float in the sea
A Wim Hof method trainee in Poland in 2016.
What is the “Wim Hof Method”?
The canonical WHM respiration exercisedescribed on the company ’s websiteinvolves take deep , straight breather , a contour of deliberate hyperventilation . After hyperventilating , you hold your breather " until you sense the urge to breathe again . "
Separately , the WHM also imply " cold therapy , " or exposure to cold . The WHM website say cold therapy can imply frigid showers and ice bath . However , insocial media videos , Hof and other practitioners often inundate themselves in bodies of water outside .
There are also paid WHM online courses , which Live Science did n’t get at while reporting this story . ( Nor did Live Science look on theWHM - focalize episode of " The Goop Lab " , featuring Gwyneth Paltrow . )
Jumping into cold water can set off the body’s “cold shock response."
WHM safety videosandwritten safety instructionswarn against combining any thick respiration exercises and piss — but Hof’ssocial media videosoften show him seemingly doing just that . For instance , a2021 YouTube videoshows Hof taking repetitive deep breathing spell and then plunging his psyche underwater to hold his breath .
" I did that every solar day since 44 years ago up till now , " Hof enunciate in the video recording . After coming out of the water , he tote up , " Back then , I was alone . Right now , millions are doing it ! " The video , which had more than half a million views as of April 3 , then cuts to a montage of people going into insensate water to come after Hof ’s Pb .
Related : Why do we shiver when we ’re cold ?
Dangers of breath-holding in water
Experts told Live Science that , if people do as Hof does in that 2021 video , they can face living - threatening consequences .
Hyperventilation can cause hoi polloi to nigrify out underwater . Before the WHM gained popularity , X ' worth of reportsdescribed people drowning after hyperventilating and then holding their breath underwater , something free frogman sometimes do because they do n’t employ breathing apparatuses .
Hyperventilation and breathing time holding decrease the carbon dioxide in the stemma and the press the gasolene would usually exert in profligate vessel . This delays the mastermind ’s signaling to resurface and breathe , fit in to a 2015Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report . That ’s because , normally , the signal to respire is trigger off when C dioxide level go up in the ancestry .
" If you slay it , it ’s like you are gambling with your life,“Dr . Frank Pernett , a pulmonic medicine doctor and doctorial candidate at Mid Sweden University , told Live Science .
Hyperventilation alone can make masses pass out , as can following hyperventilation with a deep breath , Pernett said . you could alsoblack out from just doing a breathing time hold . In all these scenarios , the red ink of origin - borne carbon paper dioxide make blood vessels to narrow andprevents enough blood from progress to the brain , induct unconsciousness .
That ’s why combining any form of deep breathing exercise or extended breath hold with water is a unsound estimate . Pernett , a free diver himself , said three of his friends , all train diving instructor , have died while training alone in pools . " If you are underwater and you faint , and nobody is there to help , you will die , " he said .
Related : How does a person freeze to last ?
This is true in piss of any temperature , but stale water brings singular risks because it can trigger the cold shock response , a reflex that cause you to gasp , the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration ( NOAA ) warns .
That reply make jumping into cold water — as Hofandhis followersdo in some videos — especially unsafe because a individual pant underwater can be enough to cause someone to swim , saidMike Tipton , a professor of human and applied physiology at the University of Portsmouth in the U.K. ( Tipton has write a guide onminimizing the risks of cold - water supply therapiesand advise cold - water supply swimming groups . )
Tipton also explained that , when your face run underwater , your dead body tries to slow your heart rate , but the cold-blooded shock response accelerate it . Activating both response at the same time mixes the signals sent to the philia in what ’s calledautonomic conflict , potentially leading toarrhythmias , or irregular heartbeats . NOAA mark these arrhythmias , as well as spikes in heart pace and rakehell pressure tie to the cold shock response , can pose a peril of nitty-gritty loser and virgule in masses vulnerable to the conditions .
" What Wim Hof did is about the most dangerous matter you’re able to do when you go into cold water , " Tipton told Live Science , in reference to the 2021 picture .
Do as I say, not as I do
Multiple people who have reportedly done the WHM breathing utilisation in H2O have died .
In 2016 , Amsterdam - base newspaperHet Parool reportedthat at least three citizenry had died after practicing the WHM — specifically while unite the ventilation techniques with water absorption . JournalistScott Carneytold Live Science that he’slinked 31 deathsto the method , draw frompublic news reportsand hoi polloi whoprivately evidence himabout deaths related to the WHM . Most were drownings , but none have yet been reassert to have affect the WHM in a homage of law , Carney noted .
However , WHM representative say they make clear their two practice should n’t be combined .
" Since we heard about people potentially drowning because of malpractice of the WHM breathing in urine in 2015 , we monish people on how to practice the WHM breathing exercises right and how not to rehearse the WHM external respiration exercises,“Isabelle Hof , a spokesperson for the WHM and Wim Hof ’s daughter , told Live Science .
relate : Free divers ' spunk rates can drop as low as 11 beats per arcminute
Of the 2021 telecasting , she narrate Live Science that the picture is n’t part of the " stock WHM curriculum " and not an instructional guide . WHM safety picture and its website tell people to sit down or dwell down in a good place during the breathing use and to never practice it or any form of deep ventilation ahead of or during immersion in or over urine .
Isabelle Hof sent Live Science the protocols for " level 1 " certified WHM teacher , and these include many of the guard backsheesh raised by Tipton and also warn of autonomic difference of opinion . However , this more - detailed selective information is throw to aspiring WHM teacher who pay for a course and is not freely available on the fellowship ’s internet site .
The WHM website’sfrequently ask questionspage advises mass to refer a medical professional before attempting the method — something Tipton also recommended for people plan to enter cold-blooded water . But under the question " How do you prepare yourself before going into the cold ? " the site simply links to avideo of Hoftelling viewers to trust their gut , tone and intuition .
— Can humans sense wetness ?
— Everybody halt ! The skill of the diametric bear society
— These deep - ocean weirdo hold their breathing place for minute of arc at a time
Ultimately , the arcdegree of danger posed by the WHM depend on whether the method embrace what Hof and his following do in popular Wim Hof - branded video or just what is write on the WHM site .
" If you retrieve that the Wim Hof Method is just the write instructions on his internet site , then there may not be a major problem because it includes monition , " Carney narrate Live Science . But if everything Wim Hof does is take as an example of his method , " then there ’s a vast problem with the Wim Hof Method because he ’s constantly demonstrating practices which are dangerous . "
This article is for informational purposes only and is not have in mind to offer aesculapian advice .
