When you purchase through links on our site , we may earn an affiliate charge . Here ’s how it work .
A leading " curse tablet " written in ancient Hebrew more than 3,000 years ago may really be a fishing weight with no discernible writing , new research suggests .
The stamp stamp - size of it lead-in musical composition , know as the Mount Ebal lozenge , has been controversial since its discovery wasannounced last March . Its finders suggested the tablet showed save in an former form of the Hebrew first principle that anticipate on the god of the Israelites to imprecate his enemies . But the fresh studies reject claim that the pad of paper is the earliest - jazz inscription of the name Yahweh and that it supports biblical accounts of the source of the ancient Israelites .
Archaeologists estimate the “curse tablet,” made from a folded lead sheet and inscribed with proto-alphabetic characters, may be at least 3,200 years old.
" mayhap there ’s something there , " archaeologistAren Maeirof Israel ’s Bar - Ilan University separate Live Science . " But with what they ’ve publish , there is n’t . "
Maeir is the lead author of one of the latest studies , and the editor in chief of theIsrael Exploration Journalthat will publish three new studies address the pad of paper this week .
His own field examines the account of the dedication on the pad of paper described in an articlepublished in Mayin the journal Heritage Science .
The 40-character inscription of proto-alphabetic characters on the inner and outer surfaces of the folded lead tablet appears to include a three-letter version of Yahweh, one of the Hebrew names of God.
Maeir take down that only X - ray imaging images of the lettering on the inside of the folded lead tablet were generate in the inquiry article ; but his examinations of them have reveal no inscriptions in any speech communication . or else , what appear to be letter are probably just indentations stimulate by weathering , he pronounce .
" It could be that there are other photos , and that the outside inscription is in fact there , " he said . " But from what we know , based on what has been publish so far , there are many , many problems with their rendition . "
However , the tablet ’s finders recount Live Science that there ’s more to be published about the objective and that they ’ll come up to the latest objections in future enquiry .
Archaeologists found the curse tablet by sifting through a pile of debris that had been removed during archaeological excavations on Mount Ebal in the West Bank in the 1980s.
The lead generator of the Heritage Science clause , archaeologistScott Striplingof the U.S.-based Associates for Biblical Research ( ABR ) , told Live Science that the original research paper was too foresightful to be release in its totality , and so it was split into two ; a 2d clause featuring the outer inscription would be published later .
Controversial claims
The Mount Ebal pill was found in 2019 amid material excavated in the eighties from the " Joshua ’s Altar " site on Mount Ebal , just north of the metropolis of Nablus in the West Bank .
Some archaeologists recollect the social system is where Joshua — who succeed Moses as loss leader of the Israelites — sacrifice animal to Yahweh more than 3200 years ago .
But others think it is a sacrificial altar from the Iron Age , several hundred long time subsequently .
The pile of debris, where the tablet was found, appears to be from excavations in the 1980s of Joshua’s Altar on Mount Ebal, which is thought to date to between the 11th and the 14th centuries B.C.
Stripling secernate Live Science in 2022 that the tablet was establish in level of earth that suggested it dated from between 1400 and 1200 B.C ; and that the outer inscription contained proto - alphabetical ” letters jibe to the modern Hebrew letters yud , heh and vav , meaning Yahweh — the name of the Israelite god .
If so , the tablet would be the soonest - known inscription of the name Yahweh .
The finders also take that other parts of the lettering may be a " expletive " calling for Yahweh ’s intervention .
Mount Ebal, just north of the city of Nablus in the West Bank, is said in a biblical passage to be one of the first locations in Canaan seen by the ancient Israelites.
The dedication and the position equal a scene of history describe in Deuteronomy , in which Moses command one group of Israelites to proclaim curse on Mount Ebal while another chemical group predicate blessings on nearby Mount Gerizim .
Latest research
As well as rejecting the finders ' interpretation of an dedication on the inside of the tablet , the latest field of study also cast doubt on its age , its metallurgical origins and its purpose .
Maeir said that the physical object was notice in spoil from an early dig and so was devoid of any archaeological circumstance .
A second study , byNaama Yahalom - Mack , an archeologist at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem , support the track for the weight was mine in Attica in modern Greece , but could n’t determine when it was mined .
A third study , by archaeologistAmihai Mazarof the Hebrew University of Jerusalem , suggests the tab intimately resemble a weightiness for the sportfishing internet unwashed at the sentence ; and although Mount Ebal is comparatively far from the sea , it could have been used for fishing in nearby fresh water supply .
Maeir noted that similar nets were also used for catch boo and may have been similarly weighted for that intention .
— 2,300 - year - onetime grave accent in Israel check remains of Greek courtesan who may have accompanied Alexander the Great ’s ground forces
— No one ' require to discover what we did ' : 4,000 - class - old Canaanite arch in Israel may have been used by cult
— Blood - flushed walls of papistical amphitheater excavate near ' Armageddon ' in Israel
When contacted by Live Science , Stripling suggested the latest claims would be taken into account by the original researchers ; but he added that critic of the Mount Ebal pill sometimes seemed to be refuting statement that had never been made by the view finder , such as that the lead ’s stock in Greece had determined its old age , he said .
He and his colleagues expect to address the objections in forthcoming studies , he state .
" I am confident that there is spell on the tablet , " he aver . " It is natural for other assimilator to reach diverging aspect , and I look forward to scan the forthcoming clause in the [ Israel Exploration Journal ] . "
